Oak Hills Community
Oak Hills presents a remarkably varied architectural landscape within one secluded waterfront setting. Cedar-sided ranches and classic colonials sit alongside an authentic log home built in 1958 by two Grumman engineers — one that retains its original hardwood floors and doors beneath a vaulted ceiling with fireplace and wood stove — as well as a farmhouse completely rebuilt in 2015 and a modern farmhouse just steps from the deeded beach. Beach cottages with original plank ceilings offer a charming entry point to the community.
Inside these homes you will find cathedral ceilings, skylights and oversized windows that fill rooms with natural light; gleaming hardwood floors throughout; wood-burning and gas fireplaces; formal living and dining rooms; and eat-in kitchens appointed with quartz or granite countertops, stainless steel appliances and large center islands. Primary suites feature ensuite baths with deep sunken tubs and spa baths, while bonus rooms above detached garages serve beautifully as artist's studios or home offices. Finished basements with nine-foot ceilings add gym areas, dens and casual bars.
Outdoor living is central to the Oak Hills experience: wraparound decks overlooking serene surroundings, multi-level Trex decking built for entertaining, gazebos and pergolas, covered front porches and covered porches off primary suites. In-ground pools with Loop Loc covers and solar covers anchor country-club-style backyards alongside expansive patios. An attached heated greenhouse offers year-round gardening possibilities. Modern efficiency is built in through ductless mini-split heating and cooling systems, zoned heating and central air conditioning.
Resident Amenities
Schedule a visit
Tour for free, no strings attached.
Learn the Oak Hills Story
Schedule a visit
Tour for free, no strings attached.
Resident Amenities
expand_lessActive Listings & Homes For Sale and For Rent
| Photo | Lot | Price | Beds | Baths | Square Feet | HOA Fees | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Loading listings data... | |||||||
Interactive Map
Oak Hills Community (and nearby)Oak Hills Residences
Recent Activity at The Oak Hills Community
| Date | Lot | Status | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Loading activity data... | |||
Community Facts
- Community Name: Oak Hills
- Neighborhood:
- Year Established: None
- Total Homes: 82 residences
- Property Type: —
- County: Suffolk, NY county
- Available Sales Listings: 0
- Available Rental Listings: 0
- Lifestyle & HOA: Oak Hills is a year-round private beach community set along Long Island Sound in Baiting Hollow. Residents hold deeded beach rights and enjoy exclusive access to a private community beach, a private community deck with sweeping Long Island Sound views, dedicated parking and private beach stairs for easy days by the water. Several homes reach the shoreline by way of a scenic woodland trail leading directly from the property. Membership in the community is remarkably accessible: voting membership is available at $10 per year. The community assessment for beach maintenance has historically ranged between $500 and $700 annually, and community maintenance runs approximately $400 annually. Tennis is among the community amenities available to residents. Whether you are seeking a full-time residence or a seasonal retreat, Oak Hills supports a relaxed coastal rhythm — mornings on the sand, afternoons on the deck at the lookout, and evenings that end with sunsets over the Sound.
Frequently Asked Questions
Learn more about the Oak Hills community and available homes for sale and rent here in Calverton.
When was Oak Hills built?
Where is Oak Hills located?
What amenities does the Oak Hills community provide?
What county is Oak Hills located in?
How many homes are currently available in Oak Hills for sale or for rent?
What is the average square footage in the Oak Hills community?
How big is the Oak Hills community?
Schedule a Visit
Ask a Question
Join Waitlist
Save this Home to Your Profile
Save this home, get price drop and status alerts, and view your favorites anytime.
OR
By continuing, you agree to receive email updates from Casamere related to your saved items. You can manage your preferences or unsubscribe at any time. See our Terms & Privacy Policy
To continue, click the link sent to
Not seeing the email in your inbox?