Reydon Shores Community

Homes in Reydon Shores span Capes, ranches, farmhouses and beach cottages, alongside newly constructed and fully rebuilt residences — including a home built in 2017 and another completely rebuilt and redesigned in 2011. Renovations are common here as well, with homes updated in 2016 featuring new kitchens and wood floors. Interiors showcase vaulted ceilings, ceilings reaching 18 feet, wide planked oak floors and hardwood flooring throughout.

Inside, gourmet kitchens appear with top-shelf stainless appliances including a Thermador cooktop and double oven. Baths are finished in Carrera marble with glass-enclosed showers; one primary suite pairs a marble en-suite bath with a separate soaking tub. Wood-burning fireplaces — brick and stone among them — anchor living spaces, and one home features a custom concrete fireplace. Sunrooms and home offices capture water views, and a lower-level wine cellar constructed of white ash with Italian porcelain floors holds 300 bottles.

Outdoor living is central to the community's character: Trex decks built for entertaining, screened porches for dinner, patios with an electric canopy for year-round enjoyment, outdoor showers and manicured landscaping. A heated inground pool surrounded by stone comes with its own pool house. Detached garages include two-story, two-car structures with water and electric plus unfinished bonus space above — ideal for additional bedrooms or a home office — while barns offer room for a workshop, studio or garden work area. Water views take in Southold Bay and Shelter Island; bay front homes offer panoramic views of Shelter Island along with private staircases to the beach and multiple floors of decks. Several properties sit on high elevation in X Zone or outside the Flood Zone entirely — no flood insurance required — on level landscaped grounds with room for a pool.