Residential Communities in

Bay Shore, NY

Residential Communities in

CITY GUIDE

+28.71% 5-year growth

PRICE RANGE:

$209,999 – $3,599,000+

MEDIAN LISTING PRICE:

$635,000 (Market Avg 2026)

BAY SHORE DETAILS

in Bay Shore, NY

700 to 8,783+

in Bay Shore, NY

$235 - $1,250

in Bay Shore, NY

Cortland Square Community
40 homes · for sale from $206,271
Lexington Village Condominiums Community
170 homes · for sale from $99,000 · for rent from $2,300
Mystic Oaks Community
70 homes · for sale from $569,999
Mystic Pines Community
90 homes · for sale from $490,500 · for rent from $3,870
Mystic Woods Community
71 homes · for sale from $499,000 · for rent from $4,200
Southwood Estates Community
7 homes · for sale from $830,000
Sunscape Community
63 homes · for sale from $579,999
The Amiralty Community
160 homes · for sale from $599,500 · for rent from $4,500
The Villas at Bay Shore Villa Promenade Community
19 homes · for sale from $555,000
Windcrest Community
43 homes · for sale from $499,000