Mystic Oaks Mystic Oaks Dr, Bay Shore, NY 11706
View of front of house with a porch, asphalt driveway, a shingled roof, a front yard, and a garage
$728,000 | 410 Mystic Way, Islip, NY 11706 | 4 Bed, 4 Bath | Listing by Realty Connect USA L I Inc
Colonial home with an attached 2 car garage, driveway, and covered porch
$729,900 | 209 Pleasant Drive, Islip, NY 11706 | 4 Bed, 4 Bath | Listing by Coldwell Banker American Homes
View of front of property with a porch, a front lawn, and a garage
$725,000 | 225 Pleasant Drive, Islip, NY 11706 | 4 Bed, 3 Bath | Listing by Signature Premier Properties
Front facade with a garage, covered porch, and a front yard
$650,000 | 420 Mystic Way, Islip, NY 11706 | 4 Bed, 3 Bath | Listing by Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
Community View
$739,000 | 405 Mystic Way Unit 405, Islip, NY 11706 | 4 Bed, 3 Bath | Listing by Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Community View
$789,000 | 304 Center Oaks Trail, Islip, NY 11706 | 4 Bed, 3 Bath | Listing by Eric G Ramsay Jr Assoc LLC
Community View
$799,000 | 311 Center Oaks Trail, Islip, NY 11706 | 4 Bed, 3 Bath | Listing by Realty Connect USA LLC
Community View
$799,000 | 301 Center Oaks Trail, Islip, NY 11706 | 4 Bed, 4 Bath | Listing by Eric G Ramsay Jr Assoc LLC
Front of Home
$599,999 | 405 Mystic Way Unit 405, Islip, NY 11706 | 4 Bed, 3 Bath | Listing by Signature Premier Properties
Community View
$569,999 | 202 Pleasant Drive Unit 202, Islip, NY 11706 | 3 Bed, 3 Bath | Listing by Coldwell Banker Easton Prop
Community View
$649,000 | 401 Mystic Way, Islip, NY 11706 | 3 Bed, 3 Bath | Listing by Eric G Ramsay Jr Assoc LLC
Community View
$609,990 | 212 Pleasant Drive Unit 212, Islip, NY 11706 | 3 Bed, 3 Bath | Listing by Coldwell Banker American Homes
Community View
$472,500 | 223 Pleasant Drive, Islip, NY 11706 | 3 Bed, 3 Bath | Listing by Howard Hanna Coach
Community View
$479,000 | 407 Mystic Way, Islip, NY 11706 | 4 Bed, 3 Bath | Listing by Coldwell Banker Residential
Community View
$449,000 | 416 Mystic Way, Islip, NY 11706 | 3 Bed, 3 Bath | Listing by BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY
Community View
$450,000 | 409 Mystic Way, Islip, NY 11706 | 4 Bed, 3 Bath | Listing by Exit Family Realty
Community View
$439,000 | 216 Pleasant Drive, Islip, NY 11706 | 4 Bed, 3 Bath | Listing by Meg Smith & Associates
Community View
$439,000 | 404 Mystic Way, Islip, NY 11706 | 3 Bed, 3 Bath | Listing by Eric G Ramsay Jr Assoc LLC
Community View
$419,000 | 208 Pleasant Drive, Islip, NY 11706 | 3 Bed, 3 Bath | Listing by Century 21 Crown Homes
Front Elevation
$429,000 | 410 Mystic Way, Islip, NY 11706 | 4 Bed, 4 Bath | Listing by Signature Premier Properties

Mystic Oaks Community

Mystic Oaks Dr, Bay Shore, NY 11706 | Suffolk, NY county

Mystic Oaks is a welcoming, gated townhome community that offers a wonderful balance of space, comfort, and connection in the heart of Bay Shore. Built in 2000, this thoughtfully planned neighborhood is known for its well-kept grounds, classic architecture, and inviting atmosphere that makes residents feel at home from the moment they arrive. Homes here offer generous layouts with multiple levels of living, ideal for both everyday life and entertaining, while private patios and porches encourage outdoor enjoyment and a relaxed pace.

The community’s location adds to its appeal. Mystic Oaks is close to everyday conveniences like shopping and dining, while also offering easy access to Bay Shore’s waterfront lifestyle. From casual walks through the neighborhood to weekends spent exploring nearby beaches, marinas, and coastal destinations, life here feels both comfortable and connected. Mystic Oaks appeals to those looking for a neighborhood that feels established, friendly, and easy to live in, without sacrificing space or style.

8,135 sq.ft. Average Lot Size
0 Active Listings
70 Total Housing Units
2,282 Average Square Footage

Resident Amenities

family_group Clubhouse
fitness_center Fitness Center
award_star Gated Community
award_star Grounds & Common Area Maintenance
playground_2 Playground
pool Pool
award_star Waterfront Access

Schedule a visit

Tour for free, no strings attached.

Schedule a visit

Tour for free, no strings attached.

Resident Amenities

expand_less
family_group Clubhouse
fitness_center Fitness Center
award_star Gated Community
award_star Grounds & Common Area Maintenance
playground_2 Playground
pool Pool
award_star Waterfront Access

Active Listings & Homes For Sale and For Rent

Photo Lot Price Beds Baths Square Feet HOA Fees
Loading listings data...
Loading listings data...

Interactive Map

Mystic Oaks Community (and nearby)
For Sale
For Rent
In Contract
Sold Last Year
Sold Last 3 Years
Sold Last 5 Years

Mystic Oaks Residences

Data loading...

Available Home Models

Aston

The Aston is a two-story, 2,045-square-foot condominium with three bedrooms and 2.5 baths. Its first floor offers a living room, dining area, and eat-in kitchen with new granite counters and backsplash, plus sliding doors to a front porch and a convenient half bath. Upstairs, the primary bedroom has an en-suite bath, alongside two additional bedrooms, a full bath, and a laundry area. A full finished basement adds flexible space, while interior access connects to the two-car garage. A brick patio completes the outdoor space.

Mystic Oaks
Condominium
Build Type
3
Beds
2.5
Baths
2,045
Sqft
—
Garages
2
Stories

Bentley

Priced from $728,000

The Bentley is a three-story detached townhome or Colonial with 1,890 square feet, three to four bedrooms, 2.5 to 3 baths, and an attached two-car garage. Its layouts include a first-floor living and dining area, an eat-in kitchen—some with an island—and a primary bedroom with a private bath. Hardwood floors, high first-floor ceilings, a front porch, and a rear patio are among its features. Basement finishes vary, with both finished and unfinished versions, and some homes include fireplaces.

Bentley
Bentley
Bentley
Bentley
Bentley
Bentley

$728,000 | 410 Mystic Way, Islip, NY 11706 | 4 Bed, 4 Bath

Listing by Realty Connect USA L I Inc

$739,000 | 405 Mystic Way Unit 405, Islip, NY 11706 | 4 Bed, 3 Bath

Listing by Douglas Elliman Real Estate

$599,999 | 405 Mystic Way Unit 405, Islip, NY 11706 | 4 Bed, 3 Bath

Listing by Signature Premier Properties

$479,000 | 407 Mystic Way, Islip, NY 11706 | 4 Bed, 3 Bath

Listing by Coldwell Banker Residential

$450,000 | 409 Mystic Way, Islip, NY 11706 | 4 Bed, 3 Bath

Listing by Exit Family Realty

$419,000 | 208 Pleasant Drive, Islip, NY 11706 | 3 Bed, 3 Bath

Listing by Century 21 Crown Homes

Condominium
Build Type
3–4
Beds
2.5–3
Baths
1,890
Sqft
2
Garages
3
Stories

Available Home Models

Mystic Oaks

Aston

Condominium
Build Type
3
Beds
2.5
Baths
2,045
Sqft
—
Garages
2
Stories

The Aston is a two-story, 2,045-square-foot condominium with three bedrooms and 2.5 baths. Its first floor offers a living room, dining area, and eat-in kitchen with new granite counters and backsplash, plus sliding doors to a front porch and a convenient half bath. Upstairs, the primary bedroom has an en-suite bath, alongside two additional bedrooms, a full bath, and a laundry area. A full finished basement adds flexible space, while interior access connects to the two-car garage. A brick patio completes the outdoor space.

Bentley
Bentley
Bentley
Bentley
Bentley
Bentley

$728,000 | 410 Mystic Way, Islip, NY 11706 | 4 Bed, 4 Bath

Listing by Realty Connect USA L I Inc

$739,000 | 405 Mystic Way Unit 405, Islip, NY 11706 | 4 Bed, 3 Bath

Listing by Douglas Elliman Real Estate

$599,999 | 405 Mystic Way Unit 405, Islip, NY 11706 | 4 Bed, 3 Bath

Listing by Signature Premier Properties

$479,000 | 407 Mystic Way, Islip, NY 11706 | 4 Bed, 3 Bath

Listing by Coldwell Banker Residential

$450,000 | 409 Mystic Way, Islip, NY 11706 | 4 Bed, 3 Bath

Listing by Exit Family Realty

$419,000 | 208 Pleasant Drive, Islip, NY 11706 | 3 Bed, 3 Bath

Listing by Century 21 Crown Homes

Bentley

Priced from $728,000

Condominium
Build Type
3–4
Beds
2.5–3
Baths
1,890
Sqft
2
Garages
3
Stories

The Bentley is a three-story detached townhome or Colonial with 1,890 square feet, three to four bedrooms, 2.5 to 3 baths, and an attached two-car garage. Its layouts include a first-floor living and dining area, an eat-in kitchen—some with an island—and a primary bedroom with a private bath. Hardwood floors, high first-floor ceilings, a front porch, and a rear patio are among its features. Basement finishes vary, with both finished and unfinished versions, and some homes include fireplaces.

Not Finding a Perfect Fit?

Explore more homes for sale in Bay Shore.

Search More Homes

Recent Activity at The Mystic Oaks Community

Date Lot Status
Loading activity data...
Loading activity data...

Community Facts

  • Community Name: Mystic Oaks
  • Neighborhood: Bay Shore
  • Year Established: 2000
  • Total Homes: 70 residences
  • Property Type: Houses
  • County: Suffolk, NY county
  • Available Sales Listings: 0
  • Available Rental Listings: 0
  • Lifestyle & HOA: Living at Mystic Oaks means enjoying a low-maintenance lifestyle supported by a homeowners association that takes care of the details, allowing residents to focus on what matters most. The community clubhouse serves as a central gathering place, offering space to socialize, relax, or connect with neighbors. Residents also enjoy access to a pool and gym, making it easy to stay active close to home, while the playground adds a family-friendly element that enhances the community feel. The HOA maintains the common areas and amenities, helping preserve the attractive appearance and overall quality of the neighborhood year-round. This creates a sense of ease and consistency throughout the community, whether you’re a full-time resident or balancing a busy schedule. With its blend of thoughtful amenities, convenient location, and a genuine neighborhood atmosphere, Mystic Oaks offers a lifestyle that feels both practical and rewarding, an ideal place to settle in and truly feel at home.

Frequently Asked Questions

Learn more about the Mystic Oaks community and available homes for sale and rent here in Bay Shore.

When was Mystic Oaks built?
Mystic Oaks was built in 2000.
Where is Mystic Oaks located?
Mystic Oaks is located at Mystic Oaks Dr in Bay Shore in NY.
What amenities does the Mystic Oaks community provide?
Mystic Oaks provides the following resident amenities: Clubhouse, Fitness Center, Gated Community, Grounds & Common Area Maintenance, Playground, Pool, Waterfront Access.
What county is Mystic Oaks located in?
Mystic Oaks is located in Suffolk, NY county.
How many homes are currently available in Mystic Oaks for sale or for rent?
Out of 70 homes in Mystic Oaks, there are currently 0 sales listings and 0 rental listings available.
What is the average square footage in the Mystic Oaks community?
The average square footage of homes in Mystic Oaks is 2282 sq.ft.
How big is the Mystic Oaks community?
The Mystic Oaks community is made up of 70 homes with an average lot size of 8135 sq.ft.

Nearby Similar Communities

Bay Shore, NY Mystic Pines 90 Homes
Bay Shore, NY Mystic Woods 71 Homes
Bay Shore, NY Southwood Estates 7 Homes
Bay Shore, NY Sunscape 63 Homes
Bay Shore, NY The Amiralty 160 Homes
Bay Shore, NY Cortland Square 40 Homes
West Islip, NY South Country Estates 14 Homes
West Islip, NY Beach Manor 6 Homes
Bay Shore, NY The Villas at Bay Shore Villa Promenade 19 Homes
North Babylon, NY Springwood Condominiums 0 Homes
Bay Shore, NY Windcrest 43 Homes
Bay Shore, NY Lexington Village Condominiums 0 Homes

Schedule a Visit

By clicking send, you accept the Terms of Service and Privacy Policy, and understand you will be contacted by Highline Residential via email, phone call, and/or text message to discuss prospective opportunities.

Ask a Question

By clicking send, you accept the Terms of Service and Privacy Policy, and understand you will be contacted by Highline Residential via email, phone call, and/or text message to discuss prospective opportunities.

Join Waitlist

By clicking send, you accept the Terms of Service and Privacy Policy, and understand you will be contacted by Highline Residential via email, phone call, and/or text message to discuss prospective opportunities.

Floorplan